Make your own free website on Tripod.com

sitetitle.jpg

WANDERING ORFFYREUS AND HIS ENEMIES

Home
YOUNG ORFFYREUS
HIS INSPIRING DREAM
HIS MAJOR WHEELS
· THE WHEEL AT GERA ( 1712 )
THE WHEEL AT DRASCHWITZ (1714 )
WANDERING ORFFYREUS AND HIS ENEMIES
THE WHEEL AT MERSEBERG 1715 .
THE EXAMINATION AT MERSEBURGH
ORFFYREUS DESTROYS MESEBURGH WHEEL
COUNT KARL, LEIBNIZ AND ORFFYREUS
WHEEL AT THE WEISSENSTEIN ( 1717 )
KARL WATCHES THE SECRET
EXAMINATION OF WEISSENSTEIN WHEEL ( 1717 )
EYE WITNESSES OF WEISSENSTEIN WHEEL
DIALOGUES AT THE CASTLE OF WEISSENSTEIN
ORFFYREUS DESTROYES THE WHEEL
CONTRACT WITH CZAR : SILVER LINING
CONSPIRACY BY GARTNER AND MAID
1730 : COUNT KARL DIES
DEATH OF ORFFYREUS 1745
PERSONALITY OF ORFFYREUS
DRAWINGS OF ORFFYREUS WHEELS
ORFFYREUS' APOLOGIA POETICA
DAS TRIUMPHIRENDE PERPETUUM MOBILE ORFFYREANUM
MASCHINEN TRACTATE (TREATISE ON MACHINES)
QUALITY OF EVIDENCE : CONCLUSION
ORFFYREUS' TIMES
Collection of Clues about Bessler Wheel
FALSE SPECULATIONS AND WEIRD EXPLANATIONS
WHERE DOES ENERGY COME FROM ?
A TRIBUTE TO ORFFYREUS
FAVORITE LINKS TO PERPETUAL MOTION
BOOKS ON PERPETUAL MOTION
ARTICLES ON PERPETUAL MOTION
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
MY RESUME
ORFFYREUS/ BESSLER DISCUSSION FORUM
CONTACT ME
Locations on Google Map
WANDERING ORFFYREUS
wanderbessler.gif

We have many narratives of Orffyreus’ life from different authors. They vary in minor details of the events in his life. In October 1982, Kadambini, a famous Hindi magazine published an article written by Chandra Mohan Pradhan.  In his article, entitled  “Ananta Kal Tak Ghumne Wala Pahiya” (The Wheel Turning for Eternity) author Pradhan, unfortunately a blind man living in Mujjfarpur, Uttar Pradesh described the perpetual motion   wheel that was demonstrated by Orffyreus at the castle of Weissenstein. In his article Pradhan mentioned that in process of seeking right man and a right place to demonstrate his wheel, Orffyreus became a mysterious wanderer. He himself became a perpetual motion man. He moved from one town to another. People got used to seeing him on road. They saw him as a shabbily dressed man with a quiet walk. Rugged and wrinkled by the sun, his face grew dark and outdoorsy. Wherever he went, people took him as a friend of devil.  At few occasions, people hurled stones over him. He was neglectful of his dress. He began to look mysterious than he really was. Deva Ramananda also says:

 

 “His big red eyes, twisted hair, and shabby clothes created a feeling of awe in the people. Nevertheless, before he was a handsome man with tossled silver hair but now under the burden of the invention his personal appearance frightened the people. He seemed entirely unaware of his appearance or the appearance of his home, but his pale eyes were yet intelligent and probing. But he was more than what he appeared to be."

 

In fact, at many places Orffyreus was accused of heresy and witchcraft. He was run out of several towns. The people of Leipzig ran him out of town for his radical ideas. He was facing problems everywhere.

.

Gärtn

er, Borlach and Wagner launch a Vicious Campaign


J. Collins also remarks that Orffyreus was an extremely touchy person, and both his enemies and friends had a great influence over him.    because of his perverse attitude, Orffyreus did not succeed in convincing his critics. He estranged his best friends and fell among enemies. Bessel’s enemies were indeed tough people and they left no stone unturned  to damage the reputation and discredit Orffyreus. Especially, Court Mechanic Gärtner and his friends were spreading rumors about Orffyreus’ trickery. Around that time, Orffyreus injured his head in an accident. He fell seriously ill, and remained in bed for a month.


 Wagner, famous mathematician of the day was also among the rumor mongers who could not digest the truth of perpetual motion.. Without any reason, he thought Orffyreus to be a rascal.  At first, when people prompted him to visit Orffyreus machine and see the truth, Wagner even refused to go and view the wheel.  He was proud of his mathematical knowledge, he calculated that perpetual motion   was impossible and against all laws of physics so there was no point in even considering the possibility. He joined Gärtner, Borlach to launch a vicious campaign against Orffyreus. 

                

One day at an early hour in the morning all of Orffyreus’ arch-enemies, Gärtner, Borlach and Wagner, arrived to look at the machine. They had no courage to face Orffyreus, as he was a truthful person. Intentionally, they went there early to avoid facing Orffyreus and mocking their ‘examination’. Orffyreus was living with his wife and brothers. When they arrived at his home, possibly one of his brothers showed them the device; they quickly finished their inspection and left. If their aim had really been to examine the machine thoroughly, they could have stayed longer. They only wanted to create the impression in the minds of people that they had completed formality of examining the machine, and it was found to be a fraud on their examination. Since the known laws of physics prejudiced them, they could never believe in fact   that such a device was possible and could operate to perform work without a flaw. They believed Orffyreus was surely a fraud and there was no need to truly examine the machine and thus waste the time. Obviously in their minds they had a plot against Orffyreus.  His enemies announced to the people that they detected fraud in Orffyreus machine. They called Orffyreus a swindler. To persuade the people to believe, J.G.Borlach of Leipzig and rest of the gang including Gärtner and Wagner published a pamphlet in which they demonstrated that a perpetual motion machine is against the laws of nature.  The drawing made by one of them on a copper plate displayed how Orffyreus was cheating.  It showed that the machine was powered from the outside via the columns supporting the wheel. They produced many copies of the pamphlet and circulated it very widely.

 

              Teubber who was convinced of Orffyreus’ integrity got worried about this vicious campaign  against a sincere inventor and on 22nd July 1715, he wrote to Leibniz about Gartners’ false propaganda:

 

“Mr. Gärtner from Dresden has been boasting that he has detected fraud in Orffyreus' machine. But how can he have detected it? Did he open the machine? I don’t know, but I hesitate to believe it.”

         

Leibniz answered promptly, within a fortnight. On August 1715, he wrote::

 

“If Mr. Gärtner has already detected fraud in Orffyreus’ artifice he should be able to imitate it. As far as I am concerned, as I have said often, I do not regard the movement to be solely mechanical but stemming from some physical principle. But what it is, I still cannot puzzle out. It will be useful because the machine can exhibit considerable energy for an extended length of time. In which case, I cannot call this work of skill a fraud if it is able to deliver what is expected of it.

         “In all descriptions of its effects there is always a lack of informa­tion about how long and how high the weight is lifted. In fact no one has informed me until now:


1.What weight is lifted during one revolution?

2.How high is such a weight lifted in one revolution?

3. How many revolutions are performed in one hour?

One could then, at least, estimate the power of the machine.”

 

On 5th October 1715, in another correspondence Leibniz wrote:

 

'I do not think Mr. Gartner will easily discover Mr. Orffyreus' secret. I also do not think it is purely perpetual motion, because I believe that to be impossible. If it is, then the machine could be enlarged to give much greater power. But I suspect that there is some physical principle behind it because its power is quite limited.' – (Gottfried Leibniz, 5th October, 1715.)

 

             It is clear that Leibniz wanted to get more and more concrete information, and it was almost impossible to be procured until he himself would decide to go and examine the machine. Meanwhile, on 27th August 1715 Councillor Buchta also wrote to Leibniz about Gärtner’s vicious campaign..

 

“I do not know whether Your Excellency has received the Gärtneriana. I have been unable to discover from Mr. Gärtner what he is planning. This excerpt from a letter written to him will tell you of recent events connected with Orffyreus’ machine. I hope that because of this we may soon know what to expect of this machine. But I am afraid that Mr. Gärtner is going to lose a good deal of his reputation.”

        

 

The enmity of Gärtner, Wagner and Borlach had its results. It made many people began to believe that Orffyreus was a charlatan.  At this time it became very necessary for Orffyreus to again convince people as quickly as possible that his machine was genuine and could actually work. He did not want his enemies to completely ruin his reputation. His enemies intensified the campaign very much before any authentic and rigorous examination would proceed. They were also constantly trying to steal the secret of invention but Orffyreus was always cautious.  


Simon Schaffer (1995) mentions that Gärtner worked as model-master for the Polish royal court and in that capacity he constructed several devices that imitated Orffyreus’ public demonstrations, including the locked-room test, but which Gärtner acknowledged as mere fraud.
*

      Orffyreus had already destroyed his previous wheel in Draswitz.  Motivated by the success of his previous wheels and to counter the criticism, Orffyreus decided to create another wheel, in Merseberg in 1715


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


REFERENCE:-  *Simon Schaffer (1995). "The show that never ends: perpetual motion in the early eighteenth century". British Journal for the History of Science 28 (2): 157–189. JSTOR 4027676.

Here is your number one companion – cute, talented and loyal.  He can sit, lie down and roll over.  Try giving him a pet and watch how he responds.  Keep your dog entertained by playing ball or giving him a bone.  Reward him by giving him a treat.  To get him to sit, double-click your mouse on the ground close to him.  Double-click again to get him to lie down.  Then hold your mouse button down and make a circular motion to tell him to roll over. You can make changes to the dog by clicking the edit settings link above. When you are finished, click the “Add to Google” button. 

If it isn’t working for you, you might need to get the latest version of flash. http://get.adobe.com/flashplayer/ 

blknex88.gif
home.gif
blkbac.gif

rnbwrule.gif

                                      Copyright © 2005 Dr. Ramesh Menaria all rights reserved.